Long Island property taxes in retirement: vintage 1873 map of Long Island

Long Island Property Taxes in Retirement: Stay, Downsize, or Move?

Long Island property taxes are one of the biggest bills you’ll keep paying after you stop working. Your paycheck goes away, and your mortgage might be gone, but the tax bill on your house shows up every year and usually goes up. Nassau and Suffolk both rank among the 15 counties in the country with the highest median property taxes, each over $10,000 a year, according to the Tax Foundation. So the same question comes up in almost every retirement plan I build for Long Island families: should you stay, downsize, or move? This post walks through how to think about it.

Why Long Island Property Taxes Hit Harder in Retirement

While you’re working, Long Island property taxes are one expense among many, and your income usually grows over time. In retirement, the bill comes out of your savings, Social Security, and maybe a pension. That changes the math.

Think of it this way. A $14,000 tax bill is about $1,167 a month. If it grows 3% a year, you’ll pay about $376,000 in property taxes over 20 years of retirement. That’s money that could go toward travel, your grandkids, or simply making your savings last longer.

Most of your bill goes to your school district. So even after the kids are grown, you’re still funding the schools. New York’s property tax cap limits how much most districts and towns can raise their total levy each year, generally 2% or the rate of inflation, whichever is less. Your own bill can still rise faster than that after a reassessment or a voter-approved override.

Long Island Property Tax Breaks Many Retirees Miss

Before you decide to sell, make sure you’re getting every break you qualify for. I’m surprised how often people aren’t.

Enhanced STAR. This is New York’s school tax break for seniors. For 2026, at least one owner has to be 65 or older by December 31, and your household income has to be $110,750 or less. For 2027, the limit is $113,550. You can check the details on the New York State STAR eligibility page.

Here’s the part people miss. Income is based on your tax return from two years earlier, and the taxable part of your IRA distributions doesn’t count. So a retiree living mostly on IRA withdrawals may qualify even if their total income looks too high. That’s one more reason to plan your withdrawals carefully.

Wondering how this applies to you?

Every situation is different. In a complimentary advisory call, I’ll look at your numbers and tell you what I’d focus on first. No pressure, and nothing to prepare.

The senior citizens exemption. If your income is more modest, this exemption can cut the assessed value of your home by up to 50%, and in some places more. Each town, village, county, and school district sets its own income limit, up to $50,000 under state law, and some offer smaller exemptions on a sliding scale for incomes a bit above that. Call your assessor to find out what your town allows.

Two More Ways to Lower the Bill

A tax grievance. If your home is assessed for more than it’s worth, you can challenge it, and you can file it yourself for free. In Nassau, you file with the Assessment Review Commission, usually by early March. In Suffolk, each town holds a grievance day, usually the third Tuesday in May. Many homeowners use a grievance firm that only gets paid if you get a reduction.

The bigger SALT deduction. The 2025 tax law raised the federal cap on state and local tax deductions, known as the SALT cap, from $10,000 to $40,000. It rises 1% a year through 2029 and then drops back to $10,000 in 2030. It also phases down if your income is above about $500,000. This only helps if you itemize, and many retirees with a paid off house take the standard deduction instead. Still, if you’re paying high property taxes plus New York income tax, it’s worth a look with your tax professional.

Option 1: Stay and Make the Numbers Work

Staying put is the right answer for a lot of people. You know your neighbors. Your family is close. You may have a small mortgage or none at all.

If you stay, treat your Long Island property taxes like any other fixed retirement expense and build them into your plan. When I put together a retirement income plan, the property tax bill goes in with an inflation rate on it, so you can see whether your savings can carry it for 25 or 30 years.

Claim every exemption. Make sure you have Enhanced STAR or the senior citizens exemption if you qualify.

Check your assessment. Grieve it if it’s out of line with similar homes nearby.

Plan your withdrawals. Keep your income under key limits when it makes sense.

Budget for the bill. Set aside the tax money each month so the bill never feels like a surprise.

Option 2: Downsize on Long Island

Downsizing sounds like the obvious fix, but on Long Island it doesn’t always save as much as you’d think.

Long Island property taxes depend heavily on your school district and your assessment, not just the size of the house. A smaller home in a high tax district can still carry a big bill. And selling costs add up fast: real estate commissions, the New York State transfer tax, attorney fees, moving, and getting your current house ready to sell.

Downsizing really works when it does more than one thing for you. It lowers your tax bill, cuts maintenance, frees up cash, and puts you in a home that works as you get older. A condo, a co-op, or a 55 and over community can check all of those boxes.

Keep an eye on taxes when you sell, too. Married couples can generally exclude up to $500,000 of gain on a primary home, or $250,000 if you’re single. If your gain is bigger than that, the rest is taxable, and New York taxes capital gains like regular income. I explain how that works in my post on New York capital gains tax.

Option 3: Move Out of New York

Some people decide the cleanest fix is to leave. Florida, the Carolinas, and Tennessee are popular with my clients, and each has lower property taxes and lower or no state income tax.

Florida is the big one. It has no state income tax, a homestead exemption, and the Save Our Homes rule, which limits how much the taxable value of your homestead can rise each year to 3% or the rate of inflation, whichever is lower. But homeowners insurance there can be expensive, so compare your full cost of living, not just taxes.

If you’re going to move, do it right. New York looks closely at people who say they’ve left, especially higher earners. Changing your mailing address isn’t enough. You need to truly make the new state your home: where you spend most of the year, your driver’s license, your voter registration, your doctors, and where your important things are. If you keep a place on Long Island, the rules get even stricter.

Moving also affects your estate plan, because states have different rules for wills, trusts, and estate taxes. That’s one more reason to review your estate plan before you go. And if you’re weighing a move on a smaller nest egg, my post on where you can retire with $500,000 compares some popular options.

How to Decide: Run the Numbers on Long Island Property Taxes

There’s no single right answer. It comes down to your numbers and what matters most to you. Here’s how I’d compare your options.

Yearly costs. Add up property taxes, insurance, maintenance, utilities, and state income tax for each choice.

One-time costs. Include the cost of selling, buying, and moving.

Your investments. Look at what happens if you free up equity from the house and invest it.

Your people. Think about how close you want to be to family, friends, and your doctors.

The long run. Ask how each choice holds up if you live to 95.

Then look at it over 20 or 30 years, not just this year. A move that saves $8,000 a year sounds great. But if it costs $60,000 to make it happen, it takes more than seven years to break even. On the other hand, freeing up $300,000 of home equity and investing it could change your whole retirement picture.

Taxes matter here too. Where you live affects how your pension, IRA withdrawals, and Social Security are taxed. If you’re staying, my post on New York income taxes in retirement walks through what’s taxed and what isn’t.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Long Island property taxes going up?

Usually, yes. New York’s tax cap limits how much most school districts and towns can raise their total levy each year, but your own bill can still rise, especially after a reassessment or a budget override vote.

Do I have to reapply for Enhanced STAR every year?

Usually not. If you receive the STAR credit, New York checks your income each year for you. If you still have the older STAR exemption and you’re enrolled in the Income Verification Program, your income is also checked automatically. Ask your assessor if you’re not sure which one you have.

Can I deduct Long Island property taxes in retirement?

Only if you itemize. Through 2029, the cap on state and local tax deductions is much higher than it used to be, so more retirees may benefit from itemizing. Talk with your tax professional to see if it makes sense for you.

Will selling my house affect my taxes?

It can. Up to $500,000 of gain is excluded for married couples and $250,000 for single filers if you meet the ownership and use rules. Any gain above that is taxable at the federal and state level.

Should I leave Long Island to retire?

Not necessarily. Plenty of people stay and make it work by claiming every exemption and building the tax bill into their plan. The right answer depends on your total costs, your income, and how close you want to be to family.

How We Help You Answer: Should You Stay, Downsize, or Move?

Focus Planning Group is not a tax advisor. All decisions regarding the tax implications of your investments and financial planning should be made in consultation with your independent tax advisor. Focus Planning Group does not provide tax or legal advice.

Similar Posts